🍕
WeHeartPizzaSan Diego
Pizza Styles
Milo's Pizzeria
Home
San Diego
Restaurants
Milos Pizzeria Mid City Gxn2l0

Milo's Pizzeria

4.5(486)
$$🗽New York Style
College Area, San Diego

Address

6686 El Cajon Blvd

Phone

(619) 462-6456

Hours

11am - 9pm
• Closed now

Price Range

$$

About

When Milo's brought their central New York pizza formula to the SDSU college area in 1994, they planted roots that haven't budged—same spot on El Cajon Boulevard since 1996, still cranking out scratch-made NY-style pies from a brick oven. The San Diegan loads pepperoni, sausage, mushrooms, and onions on a crispy, chewy crust that college students and locals have called "the best pizza in San Diego hands down." The $5 slice-and-soda combo remains a campus staple, while garlic knots, stromboli, and meatball subs round out a menu designed for hungry crowds and tight budgets. Mostly counter seating, chill vibe, awesome wall art—this is the kind of unpretentious neighborhood joint that earns loyalty through consistency, not trends. Thirty years in, still delivering.

Signature Dishes

The San Diegan

17.99

Pepperoni, sausage, mushrooms, and onions on scratch-made New York-style crust from a brick oven

Most Popular

Buffalo Chicken

17.99

Herb sauce with buffalo chicken, jalapeños, and mozzarella cheese on crispy, chewy crust

Chicken Ranch

Chicken, ranch, bacon, and tomatoes with a swirl of pesto, no red sauce

These signature dishes are what makes Milo's Pizzeria special. Be sure to try them on your visit!

What to Order

Don't miss these customer favorites and staff recommendations:

The San Diegan - Pepperoni, sausage, mushrooms, and onions for $17.99
$5 slice-and-soda combo - Two slices of NY-style pizza and a soda
Garlic knots - Pizza dough tied in knots with melted butter, garlic, and parsley
Stromboli - Mozzarella and choice of two toppings for $14.99
Meatball subs - Homemade meatballs with mozzarella, baked

Details

Pizza Style

🗽 New York Style

Neighborhood

College Area

Status

Unclaimed

Loading map...

Visit

Rating

4.5

Based on 486 reviews

More New York Style Pizza in San Diego

Luigi's New York Giant Pizza
New York

Luigi's New York Giant Pizza

College Area, San Diego
4.3(240)
•$$
🌱 Vegan🚚 Delivery🌙 Late Nightlate nightfamily dinner
casual
Sisters Pizza
New York
⭐Editor's Pick

Signature Pizza

Uncle Jesse

$20

Sisters Pizza

Hillcrest, San Diego
4.8(754)
•$$
🌾 GF🥗 Vegetarian🚚 Delivery☀️ Patiolate nightfamily dinner
casual, cozy
The Pizza Standard
New York
⭐Editor's Pick

Signature Pizza

Truffle Pizza

$25

The Pizza Standard

Tierrasanta, San Diego
4.8(330)
•$$
🥗 Vegetarian🚚 Deliverylate nightfamily dinner
casual
🍕WeHeartPizza

Your guide to discovering the best pizza in San Diego. From Neapolitan to Detroit-style, we help you find your perfect slice.

Cities

  • San Diego
  • More cities coming soon!

Stay Updated 🍕

Get weekly pizza recommendations, new openings, and exclusive deals.

No spam, unsubscribe anytime.

© 2025 WeHeartPizza. All rights reserved.

Privacy PolicyTerms of Service

Made with extra cheese and a dash of code 🧀