Long Island Mike's Pizza
About
Authentic New York-style pizzeria bringing Long Island flavors west since 2010. Owner Mike has crafted pies since age 15 at one of Long Island's most popular spots, and that expertise shows in every hand-tossed slice. Thin, crispy crusts meet house-made sauce and premium toppings made fresh daily. Buffalo Chicken pizza earns devoted fans with white chicken strips, generous ranch, and buffalo sauce drizzles. The Grandma pie and true Sicilian deep dish showcase traditional recipes. Counter-service setup features Long Island mural, outdoor seating with TVs for sports, and welcoming atmosphere. With 20 different slices available most times plus full Italian menuālasagna, baked ziti, meatball parm subs, calzones, garlic knotsāthis Serra Mesa spot near I-15 satisfies serious NY pizza cravings. Second Spring Valley location opened 2022. $8.50 two-slice-and-beer special highlights craft beer on tap.
Signature Dishes
Buffalo Chicken
White chicken strips with generous ranch drizzles and buffalo sauceācustomer favorite called "amazing"
Grandma Pizza
Traditional Long Island-style square pie with fresh mozzarella, basil, and sweet tomato sauce
BBQ Chicken
Sweet and tangy BBQ sauce with chickenāreviewers claim "no other pizza will compare"
Sicilian Deep Dish
Thick, airy square pie with authentic Sicilian preparation
These signature dishes are what makes Long Island Mike's Pizza special. Be sure to try them on your visit!
What to Order
Don't miss these customer favorites and staff recommendations:
Details
Pizza Style
š½ New York Style
Neighborhood
Kearny Mesa
Status
Unclaimed
Loading map...
