🍕
WeHeartPizzaSan Diego
Pizza Styles
Prince Street Pizza
Home
San Diego
Restaurants
Prince Street Pizza Gaslamp Quarter 57m30u

Prince Street Pizza

4.3(681)
$$🌊Sicilian
Downtown, San Diego

Address

415 Market St

Phone

(619) 501-4261

Hours

11am - 3am
• Closed now

Price Range

$$

About

When Lawrence Longo brought Prince Street Pizza's legendary Sicilian squares to San Diego's Gaslamp Quarter in January 2023, he was carrying a legacy that began with Frank and Dominic Morano's 2012 takeover of Ray's Pizza space in New York's Little Italy. The family's generations-old Sicilian recipes—thick, crispy-bottomed, fluffy-centered squares topped with handcrafted sauces made fresh daily—quickly earned a reputation that rivals New York icons like Joe's and John's of Bleecker Street. San Diego's two locations (Gaslamp and Pacific Beach) operate grab-and-go style with limited outdoor standing space, but customers claim it's the best pizza in California. The Spicy Spring—loaded pepperoni drizzled with hot honey—sells for $7 and captures everything that made Prince Street a multi-state empire.

Signature Dishes

Spicy Spring

7.00

Loaded with pepperoni and drizzled with hot honey on our signature Sicilian square crust—crispy outside, fluffy inside

Most Popular

The Naughty Pie

7.00

Prosciutto-infused spicy vodka sauce, pepperoni, ricotta, and hot honey on our famous SoHo Square

The Fancy Prince

6.25

Authentic New York thin crust margherita with fresh basil, sweet tomato sauce, and mozzarella

These signature dishes are what makes Prince Street Pizza special. Be sure to try them on your visit!

What to Order

Don't miss these customer favorites and staff recommendations:

Spicy Spring square - Pepperoni with hot honey on crispy Sicilian crust
The Naughty Pie - Spicy vodka sauce with prosciutto, ricotta, and hot honey
Arancini rice balls - Risotto, mozzarella, and ricotta with breadcrumbs
Caesar salad - Romaine with pepperoni bacon bits and croutons
NYC legacy - Generations-old Sicilian recipes from the Morano family

Details

Pizza Style

🌊 Sicilian

Neighborhood

Downtown

Status

Unclaimed

Loading map...

Visit

Rating

4.3

Based on 681 reviews

More Sicilian Pizza in San Diego

Nonna + Zucchero
Sicilian

Nonna + Zucchero

Downtown, San Diego
4.4(2,498)
•$$$
🥗 Vegetarian🚚 Delivery☀️ Patio🔥 Wood-Firedfamily dinnerdate night
rustic, casual
Pazzo's Pizza
Sicilian
⭐Editor's Pick

Signature Pizza

Sicilian-Style Pizza

Pazzo's Pizza

Scripps Ranch, San Diego
4.6(244)
•$$
🌙 Late Nightfamily dinnergroups
casual, cozy
TNT Pizza
New York
⭐Editor's Pick

Signature Pizza

Sopressata Special

TNT Pizza

Downtown, San Diego
4.5(511)
•$$
🥗 Vegetarian☀️ Patio🌙 Late Nightlate nightfamily dinner
casual, trendy
🍕WeHeartPizza

Your guide to discovering the best pizza in San Diego. From Neapolitan to Detroit-style, we help you find your perfect slice.

Cities

  • San Diego
  • More cities coming soon!

Stay Updated 🍕

Get weekly pizza recommendations, new openings, and exclusive deals.

No spam, unsubscribe anytime.

Š 2025 WeHeartPizza. All rights reserved.

Privacy PolicyTerms of Service

Made with extra cheese and a dash of code 🧀