🍕
WeHeartPizzaSan Diego
Pizza Styles
Village Pizzeria Bayside
Home
San Diego
Restaurants
Village Pizzeria Bayside Rhufyi

Village Pizzeria Bayside

4.2(636)
$$🗽New York Style
Coronado

Address

1201 1st St

Phone

(619) 437-0650

Hours

10am - 8pm
• Closed now

Price Range

$$

About

Village Pizzeria brought authentic New York-style pizza to Coronado in 2002, and their Bayside location followed in 2007 with bayfront views of downtown San Diego. This locally owned pizzeria imports New York water to replicate that perfect thin-crust dough—the kind of dedication that earned them TripAdvisor's Travelers' Choice award. The spacious covered patio seats large parties with live music evenings, while counter service keeps things casual. Pizzas range from 12-inch personals to a massive 28-inch giant feeding eight to ten. Happy hour from 3 to 6 PM features $5.99 craft pints from local breweries like Coronado Brewing Company. Whether you're grabbing a slice or settling in with loaded garlic knots and a pitcher, it's East Coast authenticity with unbeatable West Coast waterfront dining.

Signature Dishes

Meat Lovers

Mozzarella, large aged pepperoni, crumbled spicy Italian sausage, green bell pepper, red onion, mushroom, and black olives on hand-tossed NY-style crust

Most Popular

Caesar Salad Pizza

Hand-tossed crust baked with garlic olive oil and parmesan, topped with crisp romaine, parmesan cheese, croutons, and housemade caesar dressing

Mediterranean Veggie

Spinach, roasted eggplant, roasted sweet peppers, oven roasted tomato, artichoke, Kalamata olives, and feta cheese - no mozzarella

These signature dishes are what makes Village Pizzeria Bayside special. Be sure to try them on your visit!

What to Order

Don't miss these customer favorites and staff recommendations:

Pizza by the slice - Huge New York-style slices available all day
Diablo garlic knots - Loaded with red sauce, mozzarella, pepperoni, jalapeños, hot honey
28-inch giant pizza - Massive pie feeds 8-10 people, perfect for parties
Happy hour craft beers - $5.99 pints from Coronado Brewing and local breweries
Bayfront patio dining - Live music evenings with downtown San Diego skyline views

Details

Pizza Style

🗽 New York Style

Neighborhood

Status

Unclaimed

Loading map...

Visit

Rating

4.2

Based on 636 reviews

More New York Style Pizza in San Diego

Sisters Pizza
New York
⭐Editor's Pick

Signature Pizza

Uncle Jesse

$20

Sisters Pizza

Hillcrest, San Diego
4.8(754)
•$$
🌾 GF🥗 Vegetarian🚚 Delivery☀️ Patiolate nightfamily dinner
casual, cozy
The Pizza Standard
New York
⭐Editor's Pick

Signature Pizza

Truffle Pizza

$25

The Pizza Standard

Tierrasanta, San Diego
4.8(330)
•$$
🥗 Vegetarian🚚 Deliverylate nightfamily dinner
casual
Pizzeria Luigi
New York
⭐Editor's Pick

Signature Pizza

El Diablo

$24.5

Pizzeria Luigi

Golden Hill, San Diego
4.6(2,561)
•$$•🔥 traditional
🥗 Vegetarian🌙 Late Nightlate nightgroups
casual, cozy
🍕WeHeartPizza

Your guide to discovering the best pizza in San Diego. From Neapolitan to Detroit-style, we help you find your perfect slice.

Cities

  • San Diego
  • More cities coming soon!

Stay Updated 🍕

Get weekly pizza recommendations, new openings, and exclusive deals.

No spam, unsubscribe anytime.

© 2025 WeHeartPizza. All rights reserved.

Privacy PolicyTerms of Service

Made with extra cheese and a dash of code 🧀